Dear Rev. McNeer:
Greetings. A few days ago, while waiting for my doctor’s appointment, I picked up your denomination’s periodical, Holiness Today (Jan/Feb 2012). Someone had left it in the waiting room. I thumbed through the magazine with interest and was favorably impressed by the breadth and quality of its topics. One particular piece jumped out at me—the letter written by a sister in Atlanta to her brother in Los Angeles I must say that I was favorably impressed by her pointed questions, but not so favorably impressed by the picture she painted of her “Christian” brother.
You might call me a “nominal Christian.” I attend church on special occasions, but am too occupied with my career as an architect and other interests to make religion a major part of my life. But persons who profess to be Christian do interest me. I know some Christians whose up-right lives and service to their community I admire—even play golf once a week with two of them.
But the letter from Agnes set me to reflecting on a puzzling characteristic of many Christians I’ve known. A couple of days ago my puzzlement became focused as a question. I saw you and your congregation listed in the religion section of Saturday’s paper and decided to present my question to you. So, here goes.
I have no problem with belief in one God (I think you call it monotheism) who rules out the existence of all other “gods.” I don’t balk at the belief that God is the fountain of all truth and goodness. I can even entertain the idea that somehow people know this God, though I don’t make this claim myself. My question lies elsewhere.
I’ve noticed that many Christians eliminate all space between their belief in God and their own opinions about almost everything. Politics? They “know” exactly what God thinks and which side he is on. Cultures other than their own? No sweat. They know God values their own culture as superior in all respects to all others. Economics? God issued the rules for capitalism straight from heaven. Enemies of their own county? God unambiguously “thunders” his judgment against them from the heavens. In some instances this “almightiness” as I will call it, applies even to how these Christians think people should dress and cut their hair.
Here is my question: Is there something about belief in one God and claiming to know him that necessitates equating one’s own viewpoint with how God sees things? Does “knowing God” eliminate recognizing one’s own limited perspective? May I be even more blunt—are Christians doomed to arrogance, or is there something about knowing God that might encourage humility?
I once read an ancient Hebrew prayer cited in “Dear Abby” that frames my question:
“From the cowardice that shrinks from new truth,
From the laziness that is content with half-truths,
From the arrogance that thinks it knows all truth,
Oh, God of Truth, deliver us.”
Enclosed is my business card. I would appreciate a telephone or email response. Maybe we could meet for coffee and conversation at that new café near the corner of Oak and East Main.
Cordially,
Rachel
(Read the Jan/Feb 2012 article by Al Truesdale: http://bit.ly/zL0ivC
by Al Truesdale
About Al Truesdale
Al Truesdale is emeritus professor of Philosophy of Religion and Christian Ethics at Nazarene Theological Seminary. He has earned degrees from Trevecca Nazarene University, Nazarene Theological Seminary, and Emory University. Truesdale has published numerous articles (many for Holiness Today) and books. He and his wife, Esther, live in the historic South Caroline low country. His most recent books are The Baal Conspiracy: An Exposé of Everyday Idolatry (Beacon Hill Press, 2010) and Square Peg: Why Wesleyans Aren’t Fundamentalists (Beacon Hill Press, 2012).






